Mike & Gel’s Pizza

Reviews

• S Nicole M.

  star star star star star_border 19 July 2026

  What a come up! This location has struggled since Laki's left.  
  
  The new owners are off to a great start with fresh tasting ingredients and reasonable prices.  
  
  I've enjoyed their homemade meatballs on a  sub, their NY style foldable slices AND steak and cheese sandwiches. All were SO tasty... the steak is the closest I've ever had to the incomparable d'angelos.
  
  Love that they keep the place clean... And they have beers on tap and by the bottle. Not sure about the liquor and spirits...I know I've seen wine.  I am a take out only customer so just what I've noticed in the few minutes I've waited for my order. By the by, their orders are ready when promised. Sweet.
  
  Only improvement would be a few more smiles... It's got to be stressful getting a new place off the ground but friendly faces behind the counter don't cost a dime. You can be all business and still throw a free smile in every order.
  
  It's become my local go-to...
  
  Say cheese!!pizza.

• Bethany B.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 10 July 2026

  I ordered chicken parm with LIGHT sauce.
  They asked if I preferred sauce on the side. To answer their question I said yes.
  When my food showed up I was very disappointed with how much sauce they put on the meal. Seems as if they ignored my request for light sauce.
  Overall I got a good portion size and the food was decent, but my order was not made as I had asked.

• Jack B.

  star star star star star 9 July 2026

  Very good pizza place,the people who work there are awesome,they have Keno,they have a good beer selection and everyone's always happy, I really enjoy this place

• Altena L.

  star star star star star 2 July 2026

  We have been wanting to try this pizza place and must say it is one of our favorite pizza places now since Brother's oven is gone.  We ordered mozzerella sticks which were good! They make fresh garlic knots which are unheard of in this area and they were good.  Personally, I would love more oil, garlic, and parsley! I am from NY, so I am used to that oily garlic heaveness! However, the doughiness of the garlic knot was great!  We ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and we thought the pizza was delicious! Even as having it as a leftover, the pizza maintained intact and was still delicious!! The sauce is also really good! I will say originally looking at the pizza, we worried the crust was more undercooked since it isn't toasted but that isn't the case; it's perfect! We also really love the idea that they donate peanut butter and jelly and that you can buy a pizza for someone!  We love that they care so much about the community and it is really nice to see!!    They also had a nice variety of beer on tap and little bar area.  Next time, we will try one of their gourmet pizzas!! Staff was friendly as well!!

• Matheus H.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 30 June 2026

  This place was awful. Placed an order on the phone and the lady was very snappy and had a nasty attitude for no reason. I tried the wings and they were terrible. Not sure how they were made but the breading seemed soggy and not how wings should taste or look. Not worth the wait, price, or terrible customer service. Stay far away!!